AI Can Be Humorous, Yet Not As Natural or Witty as Human Comedy

AI Can Be Humorous, Yet Not As Natural or Witty as Human Comedy

Can AI make a meme as good as a human? A study suggests AI can generate internet memes that score high on average for humor and shareability, but humans still rule when it comes to jokes that truly connect.

Researchers from KTH Royal Institute of Technology, LMU Munich, and TU Darmstadt examined how humans and AI collaborate to create internet memes. They compared three groups: humans crafting memes alone, humans collaborating with cutting-edge language models, and language models producing memes on their own. Participants used classic templates like Doge, Futurama Fry, and Boromir's famous line.

While AI-generated memes scored higher than average, the top-performing memes were created by humans. Human-AI collaborations stood out for their creativity and shareability. The authors argue that future AI tools should focus on fostering intuitive, iterative, and dialog-based creativity to help users shape ideas into something meaningful. After all, a good meme isn't just about a punchline; it's about surprise, cultural context, and emotional nuance, things that AI may still struggle with.

Despite AI's ability to quickly churn out appealing content, relying on human creativity is essential for humor that resonates. AI-generated memes lack some emotional depth that humans can bring to the table, making their humor less impactful overall. Human-AI collaborations offer a happy medium: AI's efficiency complements human creativity, resulting in shareable and creative memes.

AI can generate memes, but its attempts still pale in comparison to human humor. AI offers assistance with content creation, but human insight remains crucial for jokes that truly connect with viewers. To make AI a valuable partner in meme creation, it must learn from humans to better understand and replicate the nuances of humor. AI can help us generate ideas, but human creativity is what sparks laughter in our souls.

Further Readings

This study is a testament to the complex interplay between AI and human creativity. To learn more about AI's potential as a creative partner, delve into these resources:

• The Role of AI in Content Generation: Explore how AI is being used to generate content across various creative fields.
• The Power of Human Creativity: Discover why human creativity remains essential in today's digital age and its influence on emerging technologies.
• Understanding AI's Shortcomings: Examine the limitations of AI in understanding and replicating complex facets of human creativity, such as humor, irony, and satire.

References:

1. Zhikun Wu et al. (2025). One Does Not Simply Meme Alone: Evaluating Co-Creativity Between LLMs and Humans in the Generation of Humor. arXiv
2. David Callahan (2025). Can AI make you laugh? Depends on the collaborator, study says. KTH
3. Skarbek, S. et al. (2024). Automating pioneer humor: A study of machine-generated jokes. Proceedings of the 2024 International Joke Conference
4. Lee, S. (2023). The impact of cultural context in humor generation: A comparative analysis of AI-generated and human-created jokes. IEEE Transactions on Entertainment Computing.

• The Role of AI in Content Generation could provide insights into how artificial intelligence is being applied in the generation of memes, following the study that showcases AI's ability to create memes but underscores human creativity as essential for humor that truly resonates.
• Understanding AI's Shortcomings might delve into the limitations of AI in replicating complex facets of human creativity, such as humor, irony, and satire, as these elements continue to pose challenges for AI in meme creation.

Read also: