Comparison Exhibition: Standard Horizon HX890 and Icom IC-M94D - Top-Notch Handheld VHF Marine Radios in a Showdown
In the realm of handheld VHF marine radios, two names consistently stand out - the Standard Horizon HX890 and the Icom IC-M94D. These devices are popular choices among sailors for their robust features and reliability. Let's delve into a detailed comparison of these two radios, focusing on their differences, pros, and cons, and their suitability for different sailors.
| Aspect | Standard Horizon HX890 | Icom IC-M94D | |----------------------|-----------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------| | **Features** | DSC VHF, built-in GPS, robust DSC functions, floats & flashes when overboard, waterproof with IPX8 rating | DSC VHF, GPS, integrated AIS receiver, floats & flashes when overboard, waterproof (IPX7/8 rated) | | **AIS Integration** | Limited or no AIS receiver function | Built-in AIS receiver for tracking vessels, man overboard (MOB), and emergency backup if main system fails | | **Ergonomics** | Rugged, no-frills design, feels like a "workhorse"; reliable and straightforward | More technologically advanced with richer functions; slightly more complex but offers more tech under the hood | | **Battery Life** | Generally longer battery life, suitable for longer usage | Slightly shorter battery life compared to HX890 | | **Durability & Waterproofing** | High waterproof rating (IPX8), floats and flashes, built for tough use and trust under wet conditions | Also waterproof and floats, robust for marine use but a slightly lower waterproof rating | | **Suitability** | Ideal for sailors wanting a solid, affordable, no-nonsense reliable radio; great for those who want something to trust in wet pockets without fuss | Better for sailors who want advanced tech including AIS in a handheld; excellent for cruisers who want extra safety features and tracking capabilities | | **Price & Value** | Generally more affordable, sticking to core essentials | Usually more expensive due to AIS and added tech features |
For those seeking a robust, highly reliable VHF radio with excellent battery life and waterproofing for day-to-day use or rough conditions, the Standard Horizon HX890 is an outstanding choice. It’s a straightforward "workhorse" without unnecessary bells and whistles but performs flawlessly under demanding conditions.
On the other hand, if you desire additional safety and situational awareness through AIS integration in your handheld, allowing you to track other vessels or a man overboard, and you value having more advanced technology at hand, the Icom IC-M94D is the better option. This makes it highly suitable for serious cruisers or those sailing in busy or challenging waters where AIS can be crucial.
In conclusion, weekend or casual sailors focused on simplicity and reliability might prefer the HX890 for its longer battery life and ruggedness. Conversely, long-range cruisers and tech-savvy sailors will benefit more from the Icom IC-M94D’s AIS integration and more advanced features, accepting some trade-off in battery life and cost.
The Icom IC-M94D is a useful tool for finding and tracking down a Man Overboard (MOB) in case the main set is not working. It also serves as an emergency backup for AIS systems on ships. However, it comes at a higher cost compared to the Standard Horizon HX890.
The controls on the Standard Horizon HX890 are intuitive and fall easily in the hand, making it a popular choice to take on a sailboat. The Icom IC-M94D, being more technologically advanced, is the editors' choice for backup DSC VHF marine radio usage on ships. Its AIS integration allows for direct viewing of AIS targets, particularly useful in fog or when trying to track down ships.
Both radios have proven their durability in various tests. The Standard Horizon HX890 survived various test dunkings and kept working without issue. The Icom IC-M94D, while not as long-lasting in battery life, remains a reliable choice for emergency situations.
When contemplating a new handheld VHF marine radio, the tech-savvy sailor yearning for advanced safety features such as AIS integration may find the Icom IC-M94D appealing. This device offers real-time tracking of vessels and man overboard, providing crucial information in challenging or busy waters.
On the other hand, for the weekend sailor seeking a reliable, no-frills radio with excellent battery life and robust waterproofing, the Standard Horizon HX890 would be a fitting choice. Its rugged design ensures dependable performance without unnecessary complexity.
